Judge rules that gerrymandering elections are unconstitutional

Published on


by Scott Dreyer

The Tazewell County Circuit court Judge Jack Hurley issued a temporary injunction on Wednesday against the yes/no Gerrymandering Election which concluded on April 21. This prevents the state from certifying these results.

Attorney General Jay Jones, who became famous in October 2025 after his text messages surfaced showing fantasies about the murder of Republican legislators and their two sons announced that they would appeal Judge Hurley’s ruling. Jones wrote on Twitter/X: “Virginia’s voters have spoken and an activist should not be able to veto the People’s Vote.”

In his injunction Judge Hurley cited numerous laws and the State Constitution that had been broken to rush the ballot to voters and put the language on it.

Judge Hurley’s case was RNC V. Steven Koski.

The Republican National Committee (RNC) as plaintiff went to court because a Yes vote would result in a redrawing of Virginia’s 5 GOP districts.

Steven Koski is the Commissioner of Elections for the State. The Spanberger administration, led by Democrat Spanberger, has promoted new maps and the election. State Senate Leader Louise Lucas, D-Portsmouth, boasted and promised to create “10 [expletive]1” maps.

In an interview with WSLS, Congressman Morgan Griffith condemned the illegality and inefficiency of the voting process and election: “The laws of Virginia weren’t followed and the courts will have to decide if the vote from yesterday is invalid.” Griffith is known for his folk humor and added that “the opera won’t be over until the fat woman sings.”

If the vote on April 21 is found to be valid, Griffith will likely represent an enormous, grossly gerrymandered district that runs from Cumberland Gap, near the Kentucky/Tennessee border, to Martinsville along the North Carolina border, to Vinton, the New London suburbs in Lynchburg and up to Highland County, by West Virginia. This area hosts the Maple Syrup Festival.

The case is likely to end up at the Virginia Supreme Court. Hurley ruled that the election was unconstitutional, and the Spanberger Administration will appeal. Judge Hurley ruled earlier this year that the timing and language of the election were illegal. However, S COVA allowed it to go forward and scheduled oral arguments for afterApril 21,

On April 22, Del. Wren Williams, an attorney from Stuart, summarized the ruling of Judge Hurley on , his Facebook page . The entire ruling is reproduced below.

BREAKDOWN COURT ORDER ON GERRYMANDERING

RNC v. Steven Koski, et al. CL26-266

Tazewell County Circuit Court

Judge Jack Hurley’s Final Judgment

The Court has considered Plaintiffs’ motion for final judgment and the case record.

* GRANTS FINAL JUDGMENT IN FAVOR OF PLAINTIFFS ON ALL COUNTS OF THEIR VERIFIED COMPLAINT;

* Declares that HJR 6007 is void from the start because it violates House Joint Resolutions 428 and 6001, and that any action taken on this basis is a nullification of the General Assembly’s call to Governor for the Special Session in 2024;

This argument is about expanding the special session to include more than just the budget session.

* DECLARES HJR-6007 to be void from the start because it violates Va. art. Art.

This is the argument that a House of Delegates election must be held between the first and the second passing of a constitutional amendment by General Assembly.

* Declares that the General Assembly’s votes taken on the proposed Constitutional Amendment during the Regular Session in 2026 are invalid because Va. Code SS30-13 was not followed. art. XII, SS1;

This is the argument of the 90-day notification provision, whereby the notice about a special election must be posted 90 days before the election. It was the first day of early voting that marked the beginning of the election, not April 21, as some people believe.

* DECLARES HB 1384 as a violation of the Submission Clause in Va. Const. art. XII SS1: The ballot language in HB1384 is misleading to voters and does not accurately describe the amendment that was approved by the General Assembly.

The language used on the ballot is “flagrantly false” and unconstitutional.

* DECLARES HB 1384 as a violation of the Virginia Const. art. XII SS1 because the amendment was submitted to voters on March 6, 2026 for an early vote, which is earlier than the required 90 days following the passage of HJ4 in the General Assembly.

The same argument is made about the 90 day timeline but the court finds that the election rules are unconstitutional due to the fact that they begin within the 90 day window.

* DECLARES HB 1384 as a violation of the Form of Laws Clause of Va. art. The title of IV, SS12 is not accurate because it encompasses more than one item and does not accurately describe the subject matter.

This is an argument to the effect that the law as passed by General Assembly is not a bill with a single issue like the one we have in VA and DC. The title of the bill does not explain the law properly.

* DECLARES HB 1384 as a violation of Va. Const. art. Art.

Block the Democrats from using mandatory satellite offices at certain locations. This takes away the power of the localities.

* Declares that all votes in favor or against of the constitutional amendment proposed in the special election on April 21, 2026 are invalid;

All ballots are thrown out as they are ineffective. All ballots are thrown out.

* Determines that all Plaintiffs are entitled to the injunctive and declaratory relief requested in the Verified Complaint.

The Democrats regularly complain that there is a lack of standing to bring a case before the Court and obtain the relief provided by the law.

* Finds that the equities are in favor of a permanent injunctive remedy, that Plaintiffs do not have any adequate remedy, and that Plaintiffs would be irreparably damaged if permanent injunctive remedies were not granted because of numerous violations in the constitutional amendment process, and because Congressmen Cline, Griffith, and others, who will be irreparably injured by the change of their district at this point,

Fairness dictates that it is more important to stop the election from taking place before irreparable damage occurs than to allow the election proceed. This prevents the certification of an election.

* After finding that Plaintiffs have a right to permanent injunctive remedy, the Court ENJOINS permanently Defendants or their successors not to certify the results of April 21, 2026 Special Election;

This permanently prevents the Democrats from certifying an election before a higher court’s ruling. This effectively stops the election on its tracks.

The Court permanently ENJOINS defendants and their successors to refrain from any action that would give effect to the proposed constitution amendment which is the subject of April 21, 2026 Special Election, including but not limited:

Take the following steps to prevent the Democrats from acting as if a special election had occurred.

* Update or modify voter registration records to reflect the new congressional districts proposed by the constitutional amendment.

* updating or modifying election districts, precincts or polling stations in accordance with the new congressional districts proposed by the constitutional amendment

* updating or creating pollbooks and ballots according to the new congressional districts proposed by the constitutional amendment;

* implementing new districts or maps in all congressional primaries or general elections under the proposed constitutional amendement;

This provision stops all congressional campaigns in invalidated and unconstitutional district.

(Procedural legal jargon incoming.)

* DENIES Commonwealth Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs’ Verified Complaint

* OVERRULES Commonwealth Defendants’ Plea of Immunity and Demurrer against Plaintiffs’ Verified Complaint

* FINDS Plaintiffs have complied to the County Defendants’ Motion Craving Oyer. DISMISSES this Motion and ORDER that the documents submitted in response to it are made a Part of the Plaintiffs’ Verified Complaint.

* Denies the County Defendants’ requests for relief against Commonwealth without prejudice

* DENIES any other motions that may be outstanding;

* REJECTS ALL OTHER PLEAS;

* Suspends any bond requirements for parties petitioning or appealing this final judgment

* DENIES the Commonwealth Defendants motion to stay pending an appeal.

Stops the Dems putting off this ruling while they appeal. This means that this election cannot be held within another action taken after the Dems’ appeal by a higher Court.

This 22nd day of the month, 2026

Jack Hurley

Judge Tazewell County Circuit Court

You can view the photos of Judge Hurley’s ruling here.

Roanoke resident Scott Dreyer is the leader of a team that teaches English and ESL around the world. Reprinted with permission from .

NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

Subscribe to our newsletter!  Get updates on all the latest news in Virginia.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest

TOP STORIES

Governor Spanberger has just increased the cost of living for every Virginian household.

by Jeff Reynolds Virginia has re-joined the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, and residential ratepayers are...

Fairfax Schools are at a Crossroads

by Stephanie Lundquist-Arora Fairfax County school board members will vote on the $4.1 billion fiscal...

Loudoun County School Board Debates Teacher Communication Restrictions Amid Red Tape Concerns

The meeting focused on the need to empower teachers to act quickly without excessive...

Newport News Attorney Leonard Bennett Makes Significant Contribution to Virginia Senate Campaign

Newport News attorney Leonard Bennett contributed $5,000 to the Morrissey for State Senate 16...

Joe Morrissey Campaign Committee Allocates Over Eleven Thousand Dollars to Billboards

The Morrissey for State Senate 16 Committee directed $11,889.00 to Lamar Companies on February...

Union PAC Contributes $7,500 to Morrissey Campaign in Virginia Senate Race

The Mid Atlantic Laborers Political Education Fund, a political action committee tied to the...

Dominion Energy Contributes $30,000 to Joe Morrissey for State Senate 16 Committee

Dominion Energy PAC made a donation of $30,000 on June 14, 2023, to the...

Steve Descano Policies Enable Repeat Offender to Commit Child Abduction in Fairfax

The case centered on Hiram Baca Daniel Rodriguez, identified as a repeat offender. Under...

Prince William County Teachers Face Broken System in New Scheduling Overhaul

The new schedules are set for release next year rather than allowing adequate preparation...

Autism and Vulnerability in Virginia Medicaid

By James C. Sherlock Virginia does not do enough to stop Medicaid fraud. The dysfunctional...

Louise Lucas Challenges Spanberger on Virginia Budget and Data Center Policies

The debate centers on forecasts that underpin the state budget process. Officials must account...

Virginia Republican Elections Started, Go Vote

As Virginians head into the summer months, Republican voters have a pivotal opportunity to...

Slow Start for Spanberger

by Rich Tucker Imagine that you are at a Donald Trump event. You see a...

Steve Descano Faces Scrutiny Over Reduced Charge in Child Abduction Case

The case against Jose Rodriguez centered on allegations that he abducted a four-year-old girl...

Loudoun County School Board Shifts to Propane Buses Amid Cost and Reliability Issues

Loudoun County Public Schools is shifting away from electric buses and toward propane-fueled vehicles....

Possible Investigations of Louise Lucas and Lisa Lucas-Burke. Lucas Lodge, The Marijuana Outlet

by James C. Sherlock Louise Lucas, the president pro tempore for the Virginia state senate...

Zach Cummings on Leesburg City Council Admitting He Does Not Read Police Documents

In Leesburg, local leaders gathered to examine ways to strengthen 911 services for the...

Fairfax County Housing Plan Near Gas Stations Raises Serious Health Concerns

A detailed map of the area illustrates several gas stations marked in red squares...

Steve Descano and Stacey Kincaid Fairfax Sanctuary Policies Lead to Tragic Consequences for Fairfax Virginia Residents

Jason Miyares described a clear pattern where criminal offenders are released back into communities...

Assembly and Spanberger made zero progress on Virginia energy challenges

By Steve Haner, The Jefferson Forum's June commentary outlines the energy challenges that Virginia...

Legislation to Create Waste to Energy Grant Program Introduced in Virginia House

During the 2026 Regular Session of the Virginia General Assembly, House Bill 115 was...

Parent Unleashes Fury at Franklin City School Board Over Pathetic Math Plan

The speaker, dressed in a blue shirt and speaking from a wooden podium in...

New Requirements for Handgun Storage in Unattended Vehicles

The Virginia General Assembly has enacted House Bill 110, which introduces specific requirements for...

Virginia Lawmakers Pass Bill Limiting Data Sources for Canceling Voter Registrations

The 2026 session of the Virginia General Assembly saw the approval of House Bill...

Virginia Democrats Push to Revoke Gun Rights for Hate Crime Convicts in Latest Second Amendment Assault

The legislation, described as the Governor's recommendation during recent Senate proceedings, would impose a...

Dominion Energy PAC Contributes $100,000 to Virginia Democratic Leadership Fund

Dominion Energy Inc. Political Action Committee - Virginia contributed $100,000 to Leaders for an...

Scott Surovell’s job performance: How bad is it?

by Joe Fitzgerald First, there was the plan to build a casino in Fairfax County...

Candidate Dave Beckwith Champions Homeschooling and Parental Rights in Bid for Congress

A Veteran’s Personal Commitment to Family First Republican congressional candidate Dave Beckwith, a 30-year Air...

Fairfax County School Board Votes to Scrap Veterans Day Holiday, Igniting Patriotism Backlash

Fairfax County, home to one of Virginia's largest public school systems serving over 180,000...

Significant Donation Fuels Democratic Campaign in Alfonso Lopez Virginia House Race

A donation of $4,500 was made on April 22, 2026, by Alfonso Lopez through...

Laborers Union Coalition Contributes Over $200,000 to Mid-Atlantic Political Education Fund

The Laborers Mid-Atlantic Regional Organizing Coalition contributed $204,917.14 to the Mid-Atlantic Laborers' Political Education...

Virginia Republican Elections Start June 19th 2026

As Virginians head into the summer months, Republican voters have a pivotal opportunity to...

Prince William County Sets Gold Standard in Transit Efficiency, Spares Taxpayers Millions Unlike Fairfax

The Potomac and Rappahannock Transportation Commission, which operates the OmniRide service serving Prince William...

Parke Capshaw Contributes $5,000 to Virginia Supporting Democratic Efforts

Parke Capshaw of Charlottesville made a $5,000 donation on May 14, 2026, to ActBlue...

UFCW Local 400 Sends $9,460 Donation to Virginia AFL-CIO

UFCW Local 400 made a donation of $9,460.40 on May 1, 2026, to the...

New Property Taxes Coming to Fredericksburg

Virginia House Bill 72, introduced in the 2026 Regular Session of the Virginia House...

Defense Contractor Felipe Rodriguez Supports Democrat Virginia PAC with $5,000 Contribution

Felipe Rodriguez of Vienna, Virginia, employed by Aeronautical Systems Inc in the defense industry,...

Laborers Union Trust Contributes $30,000 to Virginia PAC

On May 14, 2026, Laborers Dist. Council Trust 2 made a cash contribution of...

Charlottesville Realtor Ben Cullop Donates to Virginia Future Generations PAC

Charlottesville realtor Ben Cullop made a $2,500 donation on May 18, 2026, to the...

Virginia Legislation Proposes Greater Local Control for Satellite Voting Offices

The Virginia General Assembly is considering important legislation that would transfer significant authority regarding...

Richmond Philanthropist Mary Sisson-Vaughan Contributes Over $5,000 to Killing Babies PAC

Richmond resident Mary Sisson-Vaughan donated $5,162.70 on May 7, 2026, to Pro-Choice Virginia d/b/a...

Virginia Real Estate Developer Scott Plein Contributes to ActBlue Virginia

Scott Plein, a real estate developer based in Bristow, Virginia, and principal of Equinox...

Peake Challenges District Elimination and Budget Secrecy on Senate Floor

His remarks focused on the lack of transparency that has characterized those talks. Peake...

Nathanael Stulman Makes $2,500 Donation to ActBlue Virginia

Nathanael Stulman, a partner and head of financial services and fintech at Solomon Partners,...

Frank Conner Donates $10,000 to ActBlue Virginia for State Candidate

Alexandria resident and attorney Frank M. Conner III contributed $10,000 to ActBlue Virginia on...

Virginia Bill Introduced to Provide Flexibility for Local Election Dates

In the ongoing 2026 session of the Virginia General Assembly, a significant proposal has...

Real Estate Developer Tim Chapman Contributes $10,000 to ActBlue Virginia

Real estate developer Tim Chapman of Vienna, Virginia, made a $10,000 donation on April...

Susan Stengel Donates $25,000 to Rural GroundGame for Virginia Democrats

Susan Stengel contributed $25,000 on April 22, 2026, to Rural GroundGame, an organization focused...

Fairfax County School Board Grapples with Embezzlement Allegations in Leadership Appointment Debate

The Fairfax County School Board, consisting of Chair Sandy Anderson (Springfield District), Vice Chair...

Energy Executive Roger Sant Contributes $5,000 to Virginians for Fair Elections

Roger Sant, a longtime executive and co-founder of AES Corporation based in The Plains,...

Senator Bryce Reeves Questions Officials on Data Center Investments

The discussion focused on data center initiatives potentially located in the southside region of...

Real Estate Developer Saif Abdul-Rahman Contributes to Virginia Democratic Campaign

Saif Abdul-Rahman, a real estate developer and managing member of JR Real Estate Group...

New York Donor Lisa Primus Contributes $25,000 to Virginia PAC

Lisa Primus, a physician based in New York, made a $25,000 contribution on May...

Beth Covin From California Makes $2,500 Donation to Defend Virginia PAC

Beth Covin contributed $2,500 to Defend Virginia PAC on May 3, 2026. The donation...

Fairfax County School Board Caught in Secret Pay Scheme: Lavish Raises for Political Allies While Teachers Get Shafted

The board members involved include Chair Sandy Anderson, Karl Frisch of Providence District, Melanie...

Quinn Donation Bolsters Democratic Efforts in Rural Virginia

William Quinn contributed $3,000 to Rural GroundGame on May 19, 2026, directing support toward...

Children’s Equity Fund Contributes $200,000 to Strong Start PAC Supporting Virginia Democrats

A substantial political contribution has been made in Virginia's electoral landscape with the Children's...

Elizabeth Macrae Contributes $3,000 to ActBlue Virginia

Elizabeth Macrae made a donation of $3,000 on April 4, 2026, to ActBlue Virginia,...

Fairfax Student Champions Parental Responsibility in Push to Delay Smartphones Until 8th Grade

The young speaker pointed out that while children develop attachments to stuffed animals over...

Cameras Reveal Scale of 58,000 School Bus Stop Violations in Fairfax

The program has produced clear evidence of widespread disregard for traffic laws. More than...

Richmond Attorney Thomas McCandlish Donates $2,500 to Democratic-Aligned Committee in Virginia

Thomas McCandlish, a founding member and chairman emeritus of the McCandlish Holton law firm...

Trial Lawyer Joel Bieber Contributes $10,000 to ActBlue Virginia

Richmond-area trial lawyer Joel Bieber made a $10,000 donation on May 26, 2026, through...

Prince William County Supervisors Play Tax Shell Game: Rate Cut Masks Another Hit to Homeowners

In a classic display of government sleight-of-hand, the Prince William County Board of County...

Loudoun County Special Education Practices Draw Scrutiny Over Student and Staff Treatment

Teachers and support staff dedicated to special education programs also encounter ongoing difficulties in...

Virginia Legislature Advances Tough Measures on Juvenile Delinquency with HB 123

RICHMOND, VA – In a decisive move to enhance accountability for delinquent youth, the...

Democrats’ Brazen Power Grab in Virginia Exposed: Jeffries Vows to Override Voters and Courts to Install 10-1 Gerrymander

In a stunning display of partisan desperation, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries has openly...

Virginia GOP’s 2026 Congressional Slate: Solid Effort Everywhere Except the 4th District — What a Joke

Richmond, VA — The Republican Party of Virginia just released its candidate lineup for...

Virginia GOP Leadership’s Spineless Neutrality Betrays Core Principles on Critical Ballot Measures

RICHMOND, Va. — In a stunning display of political cowardice, the Republican Party of...

Virginia Donor Christopher Little Contributes to Democratic Women’s Caucus

Christopher Little, a retired resident of McDowell, Virginia, made a $3,000 donation on June...

Virginia Legislature Delivers Bipartisan Victory for Judicial Safety with Unanimous Passage of HB124

RICHMOND, VA – The Virginia General Assembly has sent a clear message in support...

Stacey Kincaid and Steve Descano Fairfax Sanctuary Policies Fuel Preventable Crimes by Illegal Aliens

In December 2025 a man identified as an illegal alien broke into the community...

With Virginia back in, RGGI Futures price tops $41 per ton

By Steve Haner, The price of carbon credits on the secondary market for the...

Fairfax Officials Stacey Kincaid and Steve Descano Face Scrutiny Over ICE Notification Refusal

The refusal to notify ICE stems from stated concerns over legal constraints and cooperation...

Fairfax Supervisor Dalia Palchik Slams Tysons Casino as Senator Vanity Project Amid Opposition

The supervisor's remarks underscore the depth of local resistance to the casino proposal. Community...

Dominion Energy PAC Contributes $20,000 to Virginia Democratic Women’s Caucus

Dominion Energy Inc. Political Action Committee - Virginia contributed $20,000 to the Women's Caucus...

Abigail Spanberger’s Early Problems

Abigail Spanberger struggled at key moments to set her own agenda. She stressed "affordability" during...

Virginia Senate Advances SB 106 to Combat Gas Station Heroin Threat

Tianeptine is a substance that mimics the effects of opioids and has been linked...

Clean Virginia Fund Directs $10,000 to The Impact Center in Latest Contribution

Clean Virginia made a donation of $10,000 on April 20, 2026, to The Impact...

Fairfax County Releases Fuel Violent Crime Wave

Fairfax County has experienced a troubling pattern of preventable violent crimes directly tied to...

Diane Smith Donates $3,000 to Virginia Democratic Women’s Caucus

Diane Smith contributed $3,000 to the Women's Caucus of the Democratic Party of Virginia...

Virginia Democrats Force ‘Insurrection’ Label on January 6th in School Curricula Through HB 333

The bill, introduced early in the 2026 legislative session, quickly became a flashpoint in...

Supervisor Pat Harrity Calls for Workforce Support for Autistic Adults in Fairfax County

Harrity highlighted the need for programs and other resources that can help autistic individuals...

Democrats Target FOIA and Open Meeting Laws in Virginia

The proposed changes would alter longstanding requirements that ensure citizens can review government records...

Do Democrats Believe in a Constitutional Republic Really?

The commotion over the Virginia Supreme Court's ruling against Democrats' illegal gerrymandering demonstrates how...

Delegate Thomas Garrett Delivers Fiery Floor Speech Against Democrat Gun Grab in Virginia House

Garrett, representing a rural district where pickup trucks and firearms are commonplace, used a...

Loudoun County Calls for Fair Pay for Substitute Bus Drivers

The role requires substitute drivers to manage the same title and pay structure as...

Jason Miyares Challenges Fairfax Prosecutor Steve Descano on Sanctuary Policies Amid Public Safety Concerns

The exchange highlighted differences in how local officials handle immigration enforcement and its impact...

Brad Knott Confronts Steve Descano Over Dismissal of Child Predator Case

Congressman Knott described the dismissal as a failure to protect the public. He stated...

Virginia Democrats Weigh Secret Meetings Amid Transparency Concerns

The discussion centers on the dark side of off-the-record political meetings. Concerns focus on...

Fairfax County Board of Supervisors Pushes Forward with Costly 10,000 Affordable Housing Units Plan on Taxpayer Dime

The plan, first adopted with an initial infusion of over $73 million from the...

Virginia Democrats Mocked for Out-of-Touch Remarks on Rural Life During Gerrymandering Debate

Republicans have long championed reforms to prevent the manipulation of district lines that dilute...

Virginia Democrats Kathy Tran Pass Bill Imposing Three-Year Gun, Ammo, and Explosives Ban for Misdemeanor Hate Crime Convictions

Delegate Kathy Tran, representing Fairfax District 21, was seen advocating for the measure during...

Chaos Reigns in Fairfax County Schools: Melanie Meren, Board Member Slams Lack of Data and Accountability

The Fairfax County School Board, comprising Chair Sandy Anderson (At-Large), Karl Frisch (Providence District),...

Prince William County School Board Faces Backlash Over Alleged $20,000 NDA Offer to Silence Parent on ADA Violations

Prince William County, one of Virginia's fastest-growing localities, relies on its school board to...

Parent Demands Accountability as Franklin City Schools Fail Special Needs Kids

The testimony highlighted allegations of a complete failure to investigate serious incidents involving disabled...

Jason Miyares Highlights Deadly Consequences of Sanctuary Policies in Fairfax

Miyares described a clear pattern of criminal activity associated with individuals released under these...

Taxpayer-Funded Climate Office in Loudoun County Schools Draws Scrutiny as Wasteful Green Agenda Priority

The speaker, addressing what appeared to be a Loudoun County School Board gathering, emphasized...

Governor Abigail Spanberger’s Dramatic Flip-Flop on Virginia Redistricting Referendum Exposes Voter Betrayal

During her successful 2025 gubernatorial campaign, Spanberger assured voters that as a potential governor...

Sanctuary Policies and Lenient Prosecution Enable Career Criminal Illegal Alien to Murder Fairfax Virginia Mother

Hybla Valley, Virginia — In a preventable tragedy that has outraged law-and-order advocates nationwide,...
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
×