Spanberger shuts Virginia families out of federal school scholarship tax credit, even for public school students
Ron Cogswell / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
Gov. Abigail Spanberger has decided Virginia families will not get access to a new federal school scholarship tax credit when it launches Jan. 1, 2027, refusing to take the last administrative step needed to bring the program to the commonwealth, including help for students who attend public schools.
Her administration confirmed Monday, Nov. 16, that it will not finish the enrollment former Gov. Glenn Youngkin started in January, 29News reported. The federal program, created in the 2025 tax law passed by Republicans in Congress, gives donors a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit of up to $1,700 a year, or up to $3,400 for married couples filing jointly, for gifts to approved scholarship organizations. Those groups then help K-12 students in households earning up to 300% of the area median income pay for tuition, tutoring and other education costs.
One step left, and the governor won't take it
Youngkin filed Virginia's advance election to join. The remaining step, sending the IRS a list of approved scholarship organizations, could not be done during his term because the IRS portal did not open until Oct. 23. 29News, citing the Washington Post, reported that an IRS letter in late October told Spanberger's office the step was still outstanding. According to K-12 Dive, states have until Feb. 15 to submit their lists, so the door remains open if the governor changes her mind.
Instead, the governor's office told 29News that "Public money should go to public education" and that the administration "has not seen evidence that this program would benefit students in Virginia's public schools." The office pointed to $2 billion in new education spending in the state budget.
The program runs on private donations and federal tax credits, not state appropriations. Daniel Player, a University of Virginia public policy professor, told 29News his understanding is that it would have no direct effect on public school budgets, and he said the decision leaves Virginia taxpayers helping pay for a national program without the benefit. "We in Virginia will not be eligible to receive this tax credit, and we will have to pay for it because it's a federal program that the whole country is going to pay for, and we will not get the direct benefit from it," Player said.
Republicans and school choice backers push back
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent called on the governor to act. "Governor Spanberger is slamming the door on education scholarships for Virginia children, including students in PUBLIC schools," Bessent wrote on X, according to RedState. "Governor Spanberger: certify the scholarship organizations. Stop playing politics with children's futures."
The criticism is not only coming from the right. Democrats for Education Reform, a Democratic-aligned group, said it was "deeply disappointed." Its CEO, Jorge Elorza, called the governor's reasoning "plainly incorrect" and said in a statement that opting out forfeits more than $5.1 billion that could have supported Virginia students. Steven Cheeseman of the National Catholic Educational Association said he was "deeply disappointed" and "frankly shocked," K-12 Dive reported.
Several Democratic governors, including those in New York and Colorado, have chosen to take part, RedState reported. As of Nov. 13, 31 states, Virginia among them, had told the IRS they wanted in, according to K-12 Dive.
Teachers union cheers
The Virginia Education Association, the statewide teachers union, praised the move. "VEA members applaud Governor Spanberger's wisdom in opting the Commonwealth out of the federal voucher program," VEA President Carol Bauer said, according to K-12 Dive. The union estimated public schools could have lost $1 billion a year.
For parents, the result is plain: unless the governor reverses course before the federal deadline, Virginia children will be left out of scholarship money that families in most other states will be able to use. The administration says it will study how the program works elsewhere before reconsidering. The Richmond Times-Dispatch also reported the decision.
Abigail Spanberger Abigail Spanberger Administration appropriations Budget Catholic Changes Children City of Richmond Commonwealth Congress costs Criticism Democrats Donations Education education freedom election families Glenn Youngkin governor last median income Parental Rights Parents Politics Program Public Education Public Schools Republicans Richmond School School Choice Schools Scott Bessent Spanberger state budget Statewide Taxpayers Teachers Understanding Union University of Virginia Virginia Virginia families Washington