Smyth County resident takes supervisors to court over data center ordinance he says puts farmland up for grabs

Smyth County resident takes supervisors to court over data center ordinance he says puts farmland up for grabs

A Smyth County resident is taking his own board of supervisors to court, arguing that a new data center ordinance quietly puts the county's farmland in play for the industry and was pushed through in a way that shut residents out, Cardinal News reported Thursday.

Charles Wassum filed the suit last month. According to court documents obtained by Cardinal News, he is asking the Smyth County Circuit Court to void the September vote that adopted the ordinance, on the grounds that the board did not follow proper voting procedures and ignored the county's own comprehensive plan. No hearing has been set.

New permit rules, but a bigger map

Until September, Smyth County allowed "data processing facilities" by right in industrial and commercial zones. The new ordinance requires a special use permit and a public process, which on its face gives residents more say.

The catch, Wassum argues, is that the same ordinance added agricultural zones to the places data centers can go. In a county whose 2024 land use plan designates much of the land as farmland, he says that turns the rules upside down.

"It doesn't align with the map," Wassum told Cardinal News. "The map says, this is where farmland is. The ordinance says, we're going to put data centers there. You can't go that way."

The comprehensive plan the board itself adopted in April 2024 does not mention data centers. It does say, as the lawsuit quotes, that "the rural character of the county is extremely important to the quality of life associated with living in Smyth County and the region." State law requires localities to give their plans "reasonable consideration" before passing zoning rules, and the suit alleges that did not happen.

Changed after the hearing, voted before public comment

The lawsuit's process complaints go to the heart of accountability in local government. It says the ordinance was significantly expanded after the June planning commission public hearing, broadening the definition of a data center, and that residents never got another hearing on the rewritten version.

Then, according to the suit, supervisors moved the vote to the top of the September agenda, before the public comment period. "This is reflective of the board's disdain for the rural lifestyles and land uses that local residents wish to preserve," the lawsuit says.

A phoned-in majority

Only four of seven supervisors were in the room. Two absent members were cleared at the start of the meeting to take part by speakerphone. The four present members and one absent member voted yes; the other absent member abstained.

Virginia law allows remote participation only under specific conditions, such as a medical issue. The lawsuit alleges those conditions were not met and says the absent members were preparing for a football game.

Even one supervisor voiced doubts after the fact. "I'm just saying a vote this important, we should all be here, if possible," Supervisor Rick Billings said at the meeting, according to Cardinal News. By then the vote was over.

County stands by its process

County Administrator Shawn Utt said by email that the county "worked through a thoughtful, engaging process to develop a proposed ordinance related to control of data centers in our community following the requirements set forth by the Code of Virginia." He said the county has no official comment on the lawsuit itself.

For rural residents across Southwest Virginia watching counties write data center rules this fall, the case is a test of whether local boards have to follow their own plans and give the public a real say before the land use map changes.

Source: Cardinal News.

Smyth County is a county in Southwest Virginia. Its county seat is Marion.

Email the Smyth County Board of Supervisors:
Charles E. Atkins, Atkins District, Chairman: atkins@smythcounty.org, 276-780-3979,
Michael L. “Mike” Sturgill, Chilhowie District, Vice-Chairman: chilhowie@smythcounty.org, 276-783-8865 x2232,
Rick A. Billings, North Fork District: northfork@smythcounty.org, 276-685-3445,
Roscoe D. “Mike” Call, Saltville District: saltville@smythcounty.org, 276-780-6377,
W. Jason Parris, Rye Valley District: ryevalley@smythcounty.org, 276-759-2557,
Kristopher S. Ratliff, DPh, Park District: park@smythcounty.org, 276-685-4181,
S. Courtney Widener, Royal Oak District: royaloak@smythcounty.org, 276-706-6156,
Board office: 121 Bagley Circle, Suite 100, Marion, VA 24354, (276) 783-3298. Smyth County Board of Supervisors (official page)

Smyth County accountability Allows Board of Supervisors Changes comprehensive plan control Data Center Data Centers Football Government Issue land use last lawsuit local government localities Member moved Planning Commission Process quality of life requirements Smyth County Smyth County Board of Supervisors Southwest Virginia Virginia Virginia law vote Voting zoning

2026-11-21 · 78196e8