Residents call 72-foot Courthouse Plaza apartment building 'massive,' but Fairfax City planners send it to council

County courthouse at dusk (illustration)

Residents of Old Town Fairfax told city planners a proposed 72-foot apartment building at Courthouse Plaza is too big for their neighborhood. The Planning Commission recommended it anyway.

The commission voted 4-2 on Oct. 26 to send Combined Properties' rezoning plan for the 10.3-acre shopping center to the City Council, which will hold a public hearing Dec. 8, according to the City of Fairfax. Current zoning on the site caps buildings at 48 feet. The developer is asking for half again that height.

Council members turned down an earlier version of the project in late 2025, FFXnow reported. The developer came back with a revised plan, and city staff, who had opposed the first version, now back it.

630 apartments where shops stand now

The first phase would put 315 apartments, 12,500 square feet of retail and 739 parking spaces at 10300 Willard Way and 3922 Blenheim Blvd. Once Safeway's lease expires in 2034, Combined Properties plans a second phase with another 315 apartments and 50,000 square feet of retail, according to the city's project page. The site would be rezoned from commercial districts to Planned Development-Mixed Use.

Resident William Fournier objected to the height, the density and the loss of commercial space compared with what the shopping center has today. "The building is massive and not in keeping with the area," he told commissioners.

A compromise that went nowhere

Some commissioners floated a 60-foot limit to split the difference between the zoning and the developer's request. It went nowhere. Commissioner Matthew Rice suggested lowering the building by one story only along University Drive, and that went nowhere too.

Commissioner Kirsten Lockhart said a lower height would answer residents. "We've heard the feedback," she said. But she said the developer might walk away from redeveloping the property if the height were cut. "I do understand the economics. It may be untenable."

Commissioners Paul Cunningham and Dan Drummond voted no.

What the city gets

In exchange for the rezoning, Combined Properties has agreed to pay $504,000 toward impacts on local schools and $115,605 for parks, FFXnow reported. Six percent of the units would be reserved for households earning 60% or less of the area median income, and one unit would go free to a certified police officer. About 13% of the site would stay open space.

Staff wrote that the plan "provides greater benefits to the city than would a development carried out in accordance with the general zoning-district regulations." Whether $504,000 covers the school costs of up to 630 new households is a question residents can raise in December.

Existing shops face displacement. Molly Novotny of Curata Partners, who represents the landowner, said Combined Properties would help displaced tenants find space nearby and "help offset those higher rents for up to three years." Tenants in the new building would pay below-market rent for up to three years, she said.

Council next

Combined Properties is the city's largest private landowner. In July, several council members raised the same height and density concerns residents have, though they generally agreed the design had improved, FFXnow reported.

Critics who spoke in October are expected back for the Dec. 8 hearing. Plans and meeting videos are on the city's project page.

Email the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors:
Jeffrey C. McKay, chairman@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Kathy L. Smith, sully@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Rachna Sizemore Heizer, braddock@fairfaxcounty.gov,
James N. Bierman Jr., dranesville@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Rodney L. Lusk, franconia@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Walter L. Alcorn, huntermill@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Andres F. Jimenez, mason@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Daniel G. Storck, mtvernon@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Dalia A. Palchik, providence@fairfaxcounty.gov,
Pat Herrity, springfield@fairfaxcounty.gov,

Fairfax is an independent city in Northern Virginia.

Email the Fairfax City Council:
Catherine Read, Catherine.Read@fairfaxva.gov,
Anthony Amos, Anthony.Amos@fairfaxva.gov,
Billy Bates, Billy.Bates@fairfaxva.gov,
Stacy Hall, Stacy.Hall@fairfaxva.gov,
Stacey Hardy-Chandler, Stacey.Hardy-Chandler@fairfaxva.gov,
Rachel McQuillen, Rachel.McQuillen@fairfaxva.gov,
Thomas Peterson, Tom.Peterson@fairfaxva.gov,

Fairfax is an independent city in Northern Virginia.

Email the Fairfax City Board/Council:
Catherine Read, Catherine.Read@fairfaxva.gov,
Anthony Amos, Anthony.Amos@fairfaxva.gov,
Billy Bates, Billy.Bates@fairfaxva.gov,
Stacy Hall, Stacy.Hall@fairfaxva.gov,
Stacey Hardy-Chandler, Stacey.Hardy-Chandler@fairfaxva.gov,
Rachel McQuillen, Rachel.McQuillen@fairfaxva.gov,
Thomas Peterson, Tom.Peterson@fairfaxva.gov,

Fairfax Fairfax County Andres F. Jimenez Anthony Amos Billy Bates Catherine Read City of Fairfax Dalia A. Palchik Daniel G. Storck Fairfax City Council Fairfax County Board of Supervisors James N. Bierman Jr. Jeffrey C. McKay Kathy L. Smith Pat Herrity Planning Commission Rachel McQuillen Rachna Sizemore Heizer Rodney L. Lusk Stacey Hardy-Chandler Stacy Hall Thomas Peterson Virginia Walter L. Alcorn

2026-11-17 · 51f8ca6