Richmond already paid $1.1 million over a broken library railing. Now its insurer says the city is on its own for $2 million more

Illustration of a columned stone library with wide front steps and a black metal porch railing broken and bent in the middle.

Richmond taxpayers have already paid $1.1 million over a broken railing at the city's Main Library. Now a $2 million jury verdict over the same accident may land on the city alone, because its own insurer says Richmond broke the rules of its coverage.

VACorp, the self-insurance risk pool that covers Richmond and many other Virginia localities, sued the city and the injured man in September, The Richmonder reported. The insurer says the city admitted liability without its permission, and it argues that frees VACorp from paying any part of the award.

A railing that gave way

On Dec. 16, 2024, Paul Buck and Joseph Ashely Max were leaning on a metal railing on the library's front porch along Franklin Street when it failed. Both men fell about 6 feet. Buck suffered five fractured ribs, a broken collarbone and other injuries that required several hospital stays. Max suffered multiple herniated discs, according to court records described by The Richmonder.

Both men sued, saying the city let the railing deteriorate until it broke. Buck settled in December 2025. City spokesperson Ross Catrow said Richmond paid $1.1 million in that case, a figure that is public because Virginia courts have ruled local government settlements are subject to the Freedom of Information Act.

Max went to trial. In July a jury awarded him $2 million plus interest. The city says it will appeal.

Insurer: 'no duty' to pay

In filings this summer, Richmond said it was not contesting liability, only how much Max should receive. VACorp says that admission came "without any advice or consent" from the insurer, as its policy requires.

"The City did not obtain any consent at all to admit liability," wrote Johneal White, VACorp's attorney. The insurer argues it therefore "has no duty to indemnify the City for the amount of the verdict, at all," and does not have to keep funding Richmond's defense on appeal.

City attorneys Monica Malouf and Pete Johnson counter that Richmond "provided proper notice" and that VACorp "waived its ability to enforce the clause of the contract requiring consent for admission of liability." The city also disputes that the insurer has no further duty to defend it.

Catrow said the city "can't comment on active litigation." VACorp did not respond to The Richmonder.

Who foots the bill

Max's attorney, Gray Broughton, summed up the stakes plainly.

"Ultimately, it's either going to be the city of Richmond that's going to foot that bill, or it's going to be VACorp that's going to foot that bill," he told The Richmonder.

For residents, the answer matters. Between the settlement and the verdict, the single railing failure has produced more than $3 million in claims, before interest and legal costs. If VACorp wins, the city could have to cover the jury award without its risk pool's help, money that would come out of the city's own funds rather than its risk pool.

The case also raises questions about maintenance of public buildings. Both lawsuits alleged the railing had been allowed to deteriorate before it failed. Richmond has said it does not dispute liability.

Max argues that because he was not part of the city's insurance agreement, the dispute should not reduce or delay his award. "Our view is that it's a good verdict," Broughton said.

The appeal and the insurance lawsuit are both pending.

Richmond is an independent city in the Richmond region.

Richmond city government costs Freedom of Information Act insurance jury verdict lawsuit liability Richmond Richmond Public Library VACorp

2026-11-20 · 0a90b0f