'Not even a hint': Lawsuit says Botetourt supervisors approved Google data center deal in secret

Illustration of three gray data center buildings in a green valley beside a white columned courthouse, with blue hills behind.

A Botetourt County resident says his supervisors approved one of the biggest economic deals in the county's history behind closed doors and without telling the public what they were voting on. He is now asking a judge to throw out the Google data center agreement.

Robert Dallas, a retired anesthesiologist who has lived in the county for 36 years, filed suit Monday in Botetourt County Circuit Court, alleging violations of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act, Cardinal News reported. His home is about a half-mile from the 312-acre Greenfield site Google bought from the county for $14 million.

A vote with 'not even a hint'

The suit alleges that on June 24, 2025, the Board of Supervisors discussed the performance agreement in a closed session that had not been disclosed on its published agenda. It says the board then added the agreement to the agenda as a "walk-on" item and approved it 5-0 with no discussion. The lawsuit calls this "subterfuge" that was "not only undermining the will of the people but violating the Virginia Freedom of Information Act," according to Cardinal News.

"I know this community well, and like many, I was surprised when the county suddenly announced the data center project with no public input in June of 2025," Dallas said at a news conference. The board, he said, voted "to adopt it without offering even a hint of what it was. This case is about holding our leaders responsible and having open and transparent government."

His lawyers at Fishwick & Associates allege that county officials "cultivated" an "atmosphere of secrecy" during the year and a half of negotiations before the announcement. County Administrator Gary Larrowe has acknowledged that a nondisclosure agreement was part of the process, Cardinal News reported.

What residents got, and what Google got

The suit asks the court to rescind the actions taken under the agreement, including expedited permits for Google and its eligibility for the county's third-party inspection program. Under the published agreement, Google commits to invest at least $1 billion per data center and $4 million over five years in community projects. Larrowe has said the company will pay the same 70-cent real estate tax rate as every other landowner.

Plans in an Army Corps of Engineers notice call for three data centers, three substations, an office building and supporting roads and utilities. Construction has already started.

The county declined to address the allegations. "As this matter involves pending litigation, Botetourt County will not comment on the specific allegations or discuss legal matters," a spokesman wrote.

Why it matters beyond Botetourt

The case comes as data centers have become a statewide flashpoint over land, power and water. It also tests whether open-meeting laws apply when localities negotiate under nondisclosure agreements with large corporations. The allegations have not been proven in court.

Attorney John Fishwick said state law calls for a hearing within seven working days, and his firm is working to schedule one before Circuit Judge Joel Branscom.

Botetourt County is a county in the Roanoke Valley. Its county seat is Fincastle.

Botetourt County Board of Supervisors Botetourt County Data Centers FOIA Freedom of Information Act Google lawsuit Roanoke Valley Virginia