Montgomery County board overrides heavy resident opposition to approve 349 homes on Elliston farmland
Montgomery County supervisors on Tuesday night approved a 349-unit subdivision on rural farmland in Elliston over the objections of nearly everyone who came to speak, a decision expected to roughly double the village's population of 855, Cardinal News reported.
Of the 19 people who spoke at the board's second public hearing, 18 opposed the project. The board voted 6-1 to approve it anyway.
Residents: priced out and paved over
The plan from Blacksburg-based Stateson Homes would turn more than 260 acres of the historic Fotheringay property from agricultural land into 225 single-family homes and 124 townhomes. Opponents said the project will change the rural character of eastern Montgomery County and will not serve the families already living there.
"This development is not going to preserve the rural character," said Kimberly Gers, a special education teacher at Eastern Montgomery Elementary School, pointing to the projected household income of about $100,000 needed to buy one of the homes. "I can tell you as a teacher, uh, no."
"I've looked very hard and I can't find anything that's good about it for the community," resident Tim Thornton told WSLS. "The cheapest houses in here will have an asking price higher than the median sales price for anything in that area."
Supervisors acknowledge the split
Board members called it one of their hardest votes. Vice Chairman Steve Fijalkowski, who represents Elliston, said the plan "has split this community in half" but argued the area needs growth. "The eastern Montgomery community needs more people. And this is the only way to bring it in," he told WSLS. Chairwoman April DeMotts said the fight "has divided families and that is a tragedy," WFXR reported. DeMotts also banged her gavel and warned she would have people removed after interruptions from the audience.
Supervisor Mary Biggs was the lone no vote. "I could support this if it was not for the number of units," she said. Voting yes were DeMotts, Fijalkowski, Todd King, Derek Kitts, Gunin Kiran and Anthony Grafsky.
A do-over hearing
The vote came only after the county had to hold a second hearing because of a procedural error: a legal advertisement before the Oct. 13 meeting left out information about part of the property, Cardinal News reported.
Supporters said the county needs housing options and that nearby schools are running at about half capacity. "We need houses. We need options. We need to grow," said Zach Milton.
The homes are to be built in three phases over five to eight years. Stateson Homes has said the 1790s Fotheringay house, on the National Register of Historic Places, will not be touched. The developer earlier projected average prices of about $285,000 for townhomes and $385,000 for single-family homes, and about $1 million a year in new tax revenue, according to earlier Cardinal News reporting. Residents who spoke Tuesday will now watch whether those promises hold.
Sources: Cardinal News; WSLS; WFXR.
Montgomery County is a county in the New River Valley. Its county seat is Christiansburg.
Montgomery County Education Elliston family Fotheringay Growth House Housing Montgomery County Price rezoning School Schools Stateson Homes Supporters vote Voting