Hampton prosecutor wins Crime Commission support to let police share plate reader data with the FBI when lives are at stake
A Hampton Roads prosecutor persuaded the Virginia State Crime Commission on Tuesday that the state's 2025 license plate reader law goes too far when officers are racing to stop an active threat, and the commission unanimously recommended letting police share the data with federal and out-of-state agencies without a court order when there is an imminent threat of bodily harm, the Daily Press and The Virginian-Pilot reported.
Hampton Commonwealth's Attorney Anton Bell told the commission that most violations of the law are not abuses at all, but officers passing information to agencies like the FBI "to address a criminal act that is currently going on or trying to be prevented."
"To completely prohibit sharing with a federal agency or with another state, I think it's going to have unintended consequences," Bell said. "I just don't believe that that was the spirit of this statute."
Officers in a crisis, treated as offenders
Under the law passed in 2025, a Virginia officer who shares plate reader data with a federal or out-of-state agency that has not produced a court order, warrant or subpoena commits a Class 1 misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in jail. Bell pointed to the shooting at Old Dominion University earlier this year, when a Smithfield officer shared Flock data with the FBI as agents tried to learn whether others were involved. "Everything was fluid," Bell said. The Isle of Wight commonwealth's attorney declined to charge the officer.
Bell said many prosecutors "have issues with what we are considering a violation," and that waiting on a warrant or subpoena can cost precious time, especially on weekends when judges are not available. He said that delay can endanger lives.
His argument mattered because the commission was in the middle of toughening the rules. Before he spoke, members unanimously recommended decertifying officers who break the sharing restrictions, ending their law enforcement careers, and fining agencies $5,000 for every record shared improperly. A commission report last week found 20 agencies, including Virginia State Police, the Virginia Beach Police Department and the Richmond Police Department, acknowledged violations since January, more than half tied to sharing during criminal investigations.
"If we're going to up the penalty for violating this statute, then we want to make sure that it's the type of behavior that we want to capture," Bell said.
Even the majority leaders see a role for the cameras
Senate Majority Leader Scott Surovell, D-Fairfax, said he supports plate reader systems with strict guardrails and cited the 2002 D.C. sniper attacks, which killed 10 people, wondering how much sooner the shooters might have been found with the technology. He cautioned that deciding what counts as an emergency is complicated. House Majority Leader Charniele Herring, D-Alexandria, who chairs the commission and carried the 2025 law, asked whether plate details could already be relayed in ordinary conversation; Bell said that would still be a violation if the information came from a plate reader.
No commission member objected to Bell's carve-out. The final recommendation would allow sharing without a court order in cases such as an imminent threat of homicide, missing persons and human trafficking.
A fight ahead in the General Assembly
The commission's recommendations go to the General Assembly in January. More than 40 of the 191 Virginia agencies using the systems are ending or reevaluating them, and several lawmakers want an outright ban, according to the Daily Press, setting up a debate over whether public safety tools stay available to the officers who use them in emergencies.
Sources: Daily Press / The Virginian-Pilot, Nov. 11, 2026; Daily Press, Nov. 6, 2026.
Alexandria is an independent city in Northern Virginia.
Virginia Beach is an independent city in Hampton Roads.
Alexandria City Fairfax Hampton Richmond Richmond Virginia Beach 2026 Alexandria City allow Anton Bell Behavior Charniele Herring Commonwealth Crime Dominion enforcement Fairfax FBI Flock Safety General Assembly Hampton Hampton Roads House last Law Enforcement license license plate readers Member persons Police privacy prohibit prosecutors public safety recommendations Richmond Safety Scott Surovell Senate state police subpoena technology violations Virginia Virginia Beach Virginia State Crime Commission Virginia State Police