Botetourt resident's suit says supervisors slipped Google data center deal past the public; judge refuses to toss it
A Botetourt County taxpayer who says his supervisors approved a Google data center deal without telling the public what they were voting on won the first round in court Tuesday, when a judge refused to throw out his open-government lawsuit, Cardinal News reported.
Substitute Judge Michael Doucette ruled that Robert Dallas' case under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act is legally sufficient and set the next hearing for 9 a.m. Monday.
A walk-on vote with no discussion
According to the suit, the board's published agenda for June 24, 2025, did not say supervisors would discuss Google's performance agreement in closed session. When they came back out, the agreement and a resolution enacting it were added as "walk-on" items and approved 5-0 with no discussion. Only after a recess did the board announce the data center project. Another unlisted item, approving Google's deal with the Western Virginia Water Authority, also came up that day, the suit alleges.
Dallas, who lives near the Botetourt Center at Greenfield site, wants the agreement with Google-owned Helio Capital LLC invalidated and all related actions rescinded.
"They treat FOIA like it's a little technical thing, and they can run roughshod," said John Fishwick, Dallas' lead attorney, who described the board's later announcement as more of a "cheerleading session" than a real public briefing.
County: a "technical" problem at most
Julian Harf, representing the county, argued that even if every allegation is true, the law does not allow the court to undo the agreement. He called any violation "technical." Harf and Helio's lawyer, Graham Bryant, said the agenda's mention of an economic development project in the industrial park was all the board needed to disclose to protect negotiations.
Testimony showed Google has already handed the county $2.5 million of a promised $4 million, which has paid for ambulances, fire trucks, heart monitors and body cameras, and that ground clearing has begun. Fishwick said untangling an invalidated deal would be for Google, the county and Helio to work out among themselves.
WDBJ reported that the suit could pause construction. The county said only that it is "committed to respecting the judicial process."
Residents want answers
Opponents of the project gathered before the hearing. "There's a lot of information that needs to be heard," Kathryn Hatam of Stop Botetourt County Data Centers told WDBJ, adding that she was glad the judge did not let "Helio Capital, a.k.a. Google, and the county" dismiss the case.
The case is a test of whether local boards can approve multimillion-dollar deals with the world's biggest tech companies first and explain them to residents later. Virginia's FOIA law calls for a hearing within seven days of filing; this one came on day eight, and the trial resumes Monday.
Sources: Cardinal News; WDBJ.
Email the Botetourt County Board/Council:
Walter Michael, wmichael@botetourtva.gov,
Brandon Nicely, bwnicely@botetourtva.gov,
Linda Rottman, lrottman@botetourtva.gov,
Mac Scothorn, mscothorn@botetourtva.gov,
Tim Snyder, tsnyder@botetourtva.gov
Botetourt County is a county in the Roanoke Valley. Its county seat is Fincastle.
Botetourt County allow body cameras Botetourt County Closed Data Center Data Centers discussion economic development First FOIA Freedom of Information Act Google Government Helio Capital lawsuit Process Session substitute thing thing Virginia vote Voting